GenToday-L Archive

MISCONCEPTIONS of Genealogy

by Michael John Neill

PUBLISHED WITH PERMISSION in the April 2000 edition of GenToday-L

This is a semi-serious look at some misconceptions that genealogists (and non-genealogists) have about family history.

1) WE ALL HAVE A FAMOUS ANCESTOR, SOMEWHERE.
I've got the names of over three hundred of my ancestors and have yet to have any of them qualify as "famous." In some cases, you may want to reconsider being related to someone famous. Hard-working, law-abiding relatives are nothing to be ashamed of. Try and document your ancestors accurately, whether they were famous or not.

2) THERE ARE NO "EARLY" BABIES OR SHADY STORIES IN MY FAMILY TREE.
Trace your ancestry completely for six generations and then we will talk.

3) THERE WERE THREE BROTHERS WITH THE LAST NAME OF [TAKEYOURPICK]WHO CAME TO AMERICA. WE DESCEND FROM THE YOUNGEST (OLDEST, MIDDLE, TALLEST, SMARTEST,ETC.)
If this is true, then the number of families who had three sons is beyond statistical expectations. Check it out.

4) IMMIGRANTS WERE ALL POOR.
There's no doubt that the vast majority of them were and came to America with only the clothes on their backs. Once in a while though, you'll find one who had a little bit of money and came to America hoping to make more.

5) LIFE BEFORE 1900 WAS ONE OF BUCOLIC PASTORAL BLISS, DOTTED BY BARN RAISINGS AND CHURCH SOCIALS.
Life before 1900 was hard. No running water, no electricity, no law (in some areas), rudimentary medical care (if any), child labor, and few of life's creature comforts. This only scratches the surface. I'm not even so certain life was "simple." If I want a loaf of bread, I go to the store. Great-great-grandma likely did not.

6) EVERYONE LIKES TO HEAR THE TALES OF "NOTORIOUS" ANCESTORS.
Not everyone will think the story of great-great-great-grandma's four husbands, two divorces, involvement in a murder, and the running of a tavern should be included in the family history.

7) CENSUS AGES ARE ALWAYS CORRECT.
You must be kidding.

8) OFFICIAL RECORDS SHOULD NOT CONTAIN ERRORS.
They do. The best way to deal with it is to try and research around it where possible.

9) GENEALOGISTS ARE ALL RETIRED.
Not so. There are genealogists out there who have yet to hit forty or retirement. If you see one who has yet to hit puberty, tell them to interview their grandparents now. Most of all encourage them, gently.

10) GENEALOGY IS NOT AN INTELLECTUAL HOBBY.
Ever tried to read through (and understand) sixty pages of court records from the 1840s? I've taken calculus exams that made more sense. Same thing goes for platting property in metes and bounds. Talk about applied mathematics.

11) MY FAMILY HAS A CASTLE IN EUROPE.
Some did, but don't believe it until you see it. Don't really believe it until you see the deed, title, etc.

12) MY ANCESTOR SERVED WITH WASHINGTON, LEE, GRANT, ETC.
Choose your war, take your pick. There are lots of these stories. Check them out before believing them. Document your ancestor's service, accurately.

13) I GOT IT ON THE INTERNET, THEREFORE IT MUST BE TRUE.
Nope.

14) I GOT IT ON THE INTERNET, THEREFORE IT MUST BE FALSE.
Nope.

15) I CAN DO MY GENEALOGY ENTIRELY VIA THE INTERNET.
Nope.

16) I CAN DO MY GENEALOGY WITHOUT THE INTERNET.
Possibly, but it really saves time.

17) THE RECORDS IN STATE XYZ ARE CLOSING BECAUSE IT WAS POSTED TO THE GENEALOGY MAILING LIST FOR THAT STATE.
Check out rumors before you spread them. Think before you forward or copy and paste this type of information to other people or lists. [Editor's Note: For more on this, see the FGS Suggested Steps for Action in the Feb. 9 Ancestry Daily News at: http://www.ancestry.com/learn/columns/dailyarchive/02-09-00.htm#4]

18) I CAN DO ALL MY RESEARCH ONLY USING VITAL RECORDS, OBITUARIES, AND CENSUS RECORDS.
Goodness! There's a vast treasure trove of other sources out there that you can utilize.

19) MY SURNAME HAS ALWAYS BEEN SPELLED THE SAME WAY, WE NEVER CHANGED IT.
Maybe, but then again, maybe not.

20) EVERYONE REPLIES TO E-MAIL IMMEDIATELY.
Some genealogists have non-genealogy commitments, such as family and employment. Be patient and wait a few days before posting a follow-up e-mail.

21) I CAN TRACE MY ANCESTRY IN ONE AFTERNOON AT THE COMPUTER.
Time for a reality check.

22) I CAN TRACE MY ANCESTORS IN AN AFTERNOON AT THE FAMILY HISTORY CENTER.
(See number 21)

23) SOMEONE HAS ALREADY TRACED MY ENTIRE FAMILY TREE. I JUST HAVE TO FIND IT.
That's the tricky part-finding it! Then comes the fun of documenting it.

24) DOCUMENTATION IS ONLY FOR GENEALOGICAL GEEKS WHO GET CHEAP THRILLS BY ASKING, "WHERE DID YOU FIND IT?"
How will you ever compare three different birth dates for Grandpa if you don't know where you obtained each date?

25) GENEALOGISTS ARE NUTS.
More likely they are truly focused on their research. However, one correspondent told me that working on genealogy "beats spending all my free time at a bar."

26) GENEALOGISTS ARE RUDE AT THE COURTHOUSE OR LIBRARY.
Genealogists are people and a few are rude. Just make certain it's not you. No family historian wants to walk into the courthouse just after the most obnoxious genealogist on the planet has left the building.

27) GENEALOGY IS BORING.
You must be kidding. I've learned a great deal about history, culture, and myself researching my own family.

28) YOU OUGHT TO BE DONE WITH THAT FAMILY HISTORY BY NOW.
Well, I would except every time I find one ancestor I have two more parents to learn about.

29) THERE IS ONE BEST GENEALOGICAL SOFTWARE PACKAGE.
Most have their pros and cons. Pick one that works for you, keep alert for new packages, but only change when you have good reason to. Time spent upgrading and upgrading and constantly learning new packages can be spent doing research.

30) YOU ARE COMPLETELY ADDICTED IF YOU SEARCH THE INGREDIENT LIST OF YOUR BREAKFAST CEREAL FOR YOUR ANCESTRAL SURNAMES.
This is likely true, but I'm not admitting to this one in public!

31) GENEALOGY IS EXPENSIVE
The documentation can be expensive. Many will share copies but some will not. Spread it out over time if you don't have immediate resources.


Queries

Looking for location of Giddingsville, New York. My gggrandfather Giles P. Ransom livedin Giddingsville after marriage to Cynthia Harlow. danmar@pecos-nm.co

Researching all Tuxhorn families. We Tuxhorns & descendents have lots of info to share. All Tuxhorn families are related. About to make major breakthrough in Germany. Lwhansel@aol.com

Jonas HATFIELD born Wales 1763.They came to PA. abt 1773. Md Rachel Janny, poss.the widow of Lleweylln in Ky. Had 7 ch. Jonas died Ind 1813. Any info appreciated. JSuman@aol.com

Looking for anyone related to Henry Brinkhoff from Germany, born 23 July 1856 came to US 22 August 1872. Rec'd Naturalization papers in Portage Co. 7 Oct 1886 Any info to TWhite7963@aol.com

David JENKINS bn c 1863 Glamorgan Wales to Thomas JENKINS & Ann LEWIS, emigrated to America 1880s; md & had Thomas, who had David, bn 1925. Australian cousins wish to make contact. jillmarg@tpgi.com.au

Researchiong 1851 Oregon Trail Migration & collecting journals, recollections & narratives.If you have an interest and/or names of ancestors who went west that year,contact me. Have collected eighty journals, 3,400+ names so far. skipb@nh.ultranet.com

Researching Abraham GRIMES b. abt 1823 & Mary JOHNSON b. abt. 1830 Patterson, La., m. Nov. 22, 1869. Children: Sarah, Frank, Martha, Washington, Elizabeth, Easter, Isabella, Marshall & Hannah all b. in Patterson, La. Claybas@aol.com

Seeking info: Frederick & Riney (PICKETT) MINGO & children: Cary, Isham, Shedrick, Lazuraus, Earnest, Martha, Mary, & Savinia MINGO. All of Patterson St. Mary Parish, La., bet 1880 & 1900.Claybas@aol.com

Looking for any information on the surname BESTIMT. ladycarver@mvtel.net

HODGKINSON & HOWARD. Emigrated from Preston, Lancashire England at end of 1800's and early 1900's. Settling in Fall River and New Bedford Massachusetts USA. Kath. (kathb123@aol.com)

HELPFUL HINT: Please take the time to capitalize the surnames, it makes it easier to find family names. This is the internationally accepted standard for surnames.

Additional Articles:

  • Sound Genealogical Research
  • Do's and Dont's with Census Records
  • What to Save

    The Genealogy Lady established the "Genealogy Today" newsletter in April 1997. She answers questions online at New-Jerusalem.com, and sells books at her Genealogy Book Store.

  • What's New in Genealogy ... Today!
    click to view original photo